TopDrawerSoccer Facebook TopDrawerSoccer Twitter The 91st Minute RSS

The literary lives of MLS’ best players

Written by Will Parchman


This was a fun project. For each MLS team, I’ve chosen a key contributor and tied his playing style to a literary luminary I respect in some fashion. It’s essentially pairing the playing style with a mix of writing style and lifestyle, which is imperfect but ended up lining up surprisingly well in some cases. Some of these are more absurd than others, but all are rooted in how I tend to view these guys when I watch them.

In the same way that coders sometimes view the world analytically, I tend to view it in words. Here are a few.

Chicago Fire

Mike Magee (Kurt Vonnegut): Compact and whimsical, there’s frequently a hard, malicious edge underneath what sometimes appears to be a carefree veneer. Prolific. Donning a keeper’s jersey to save LA’s bacon was Magee’s Cat’s Cradle. Once you stopped laughing, you saw the seriousness in it. Absolutely zero pretension.

Chivas USA

Dan Kennedy (Jack Kerouac): Surrounded by degradation and madness at nearly all times. Surprised to not see him descend into an ether-driven insanity based on his work environment, some of which was chosen and some innate. Incredible talent slowly bitten away at the edges by vultures in his inner circle without the wherewithal to have his best interests in mind. Dharma Bum.

Colorado Rapids

Shane O’Neill (Jonathan Safran Foer): Ascended to tall heights incredibly early in his career. Everything is illuminated. Mixed heritage adds to the richness and diversity in his style. Can be a polarizing figure among critics due to his age and relative lack of international acclaim. Probably a genius, but the jury’s out. Younger brother may actually end up being better than he is.

Columbus Crew

Federico Higuain (Gabriel Garcia Marquez): Maybe the best in his league, but injuries and the brief interjection of ordinary in the midst of unbelievable genius occasionally tears down the wall of his invincibility. Turns convention on its head by taking Latin flair and making it hard-bitten and real. Weaves intricate webs over the course of 90 minutes and sometimes you merely shake your head with the misunderstanding of awe.

DC United

Luis Silva (Joseph Conrad): In the heart of darkness itself. A titan of industry among the withered palm fronds and strangling, thorned vines of the jungle. From smog-choked industrial England to malarial Congo, no relief despite a transfer in scenery. Better than his contemporaries probably realize, but bound to have his genius edged off by averse conditions.

FC Dallas

George John (Nikos Kazantzakis): His is the story of a young Greek born outside his mother country attempting to find his place in the world. Schellas Hyndman is his Zorba. Paired with a mysterious, boisterous coach, a sense that he’s needed elsewhere pervades his thoughts until Zorba leaves him for good. Has the ability and want-to to some day depart for the mainland when he’s ready.

Houston Dynamo

Brad Davis (Gertrude Stein): Destined to be The Forgotten One of a great generation despite latent talent. Operates best as a facilitator, housing younger, more sharpened skill while buttressing it with modest ability of his own. Provided an assist to an entire nation he did not necessarily care for, allowing it the comfort of knowing its great tradition will carry on on the biggest stage. Big ears.

LA Galaxy

Landon Donovan (F. Scott Fitzgerald): Arguably the greatest American of his ilk ever, certainly the greatest at what he did in his time. Unbelievably cerebral, tackling some of the great mysteries of our age with an immense vocabulary and a small bit of compactness amidst a constellation of genius. Left his shores but struggled with bouts of depression and restlessness until returning home. Beautiful and damned.

Montreal Impact

Marco Di Vaio (Salman Rushdie): Could rest on his laurels the rest of his career based on his earlier exploits, but continues churning out meaningful work at an older age despite detractors. Offside continually, but best when he’s flirting with the line between what’s accepted and what is generally not. By pushing the boundaries, he creates new space for conversation and, most importantly, adds spice.

New England Revolution

Juan Agudelo (J.K. Rowling): Wows onlookers with visions of vast unexplored realms within a country used to far more staid, boring patterns. Still, there’s plenty to critique about his style, which tends to pander to a younger audience and lacks a dash of maturity. Currently defined by potential and rapid, early success. It remains to be seen whether the follow-up will show literary growth.

New York Red Bulls

Thierry Henry (Oscar Wilde): There is whimsy and genius at play here, and he knows it well. The acknowledgment of his greatness is in fact one of his most disarming tools, allowing him to play uninhibited and without reservation. Flamboyant, glittering and utterly impossible to miss. Had the ability and the power to screw over the Irish with one hand.

Philadelphia Union

Jack McInerney (Jack London): Talented kid rushed out for the gold fields and had some success before developing scurvy and being forced to scale back his expectations. Maybe not scurvy exactly. A young slump? Possesses a fighter’s spirit and overcomes lack of intricate vocabulary and razor-sharp wit with determination and ruthlessness in front of goal. Will probably never win over everybody, but enough to carve out a niche.

Portland Timbers

Will Johnson (Stephen King): Something about his face tends to piss people off. Still, unbelievably prolific and can incite the characters around him to do both horrifying and magnificent things. Unbridled leader despite lacking the real literary gravitas of some of his peers and his more lyrical forebears. Not afraid of mixing things up and arguably the most stable presence in the American game today.

Real Salt Lake

Kyle Beckerman (Ernest Hemingway): Not an ounce of artifice here, and his brilliance is immediately recognizable to those who find beauty in spare prose. No word is out of place, no step is unmeasured and no thought is wasted in the midst of his slavish opposition to ornamentation. The lack of flair and flash can leave some wanting more, but operating within this framework there are perhaps none better on these shores.

San Jose Earthquakes

Chris Wondolowski (Hunter S. Thompson): Depraved perhaps of the kind of talent and self-promotion that might have otherwise made him a bigger crossover hit, he’s nonetheless one of the most uniquely productive Americans of our age. Has his pulse on the cultural zeitgeist and can often dictate a game simply by being in it. Unfortunately, after a brief spurt of incredible productivity, age and natural limitations eventually took their toll.

Seattle Sounders

Clint Dempsey (William Faulkner): A genius who was tempered by and came of age in the south. Unbelievable foresight and vision, an endless supply of words and an ability to use his stream of consciousness like a weapon. Which has occasionally been the problem. An acute awareness of his talents often leads him to overuse them and become bogged down by their weight. When he’s not being verbose, there are few (if any) better.

Sporting Kansas City

Aurelien Collin (James Joyce): There are times when he seems to make little sense, and he can tend to tire out your cerebral core with threads that seem to tie themselves in knots. But ultimately he is razor-sharp (sometimes with a bit too much bite), and while his works tend at times to fly beyond the realm of understanding, they are generally productive. One tends to wear funny things in real life. The other wears pimp gear in a meme.

Vancouver Whitecaps

Camilo (Homer): What beautiful poetry. His play is hardly just prose, instead imbued with the kind of lyrical fancy and delicate silk that crafts entire worlds with a mere touch. Some of what he does seems to be from a different time, and he can tend to wrap his stories in so much rosewater that the real graft of it can be lost in translation. But he can transport you to a different place entirely, which is a rare gift.

Toronto FC 

*pick one* (Cormac McCarthy): A bloody mess.


Tags:  ,
  • shirley zusi

    This was a noble and refreshing literary work in its own right and though quite spot on, I find it intriguing that often the man on the field is a different creature than the entity strolling about…lots of layers…a good thing! Enjoyed this as I do a lot of Charles Gooche’s analyses in KC!…you both write like these guys play soccer…gifted! Thanks for sharing your blessings!

  • Sgc

    Hmm. What I got from this:

    Donovan — one hit wonder
    O’Neill — has a brother who knows how soccer explains the world
    Silva — sympathizes with anarchist terrorism
    Kennedy — all-right-a-rooney!
    Di Vaio — his story begins with all four of his grandparents
    Agudelo — better thought of critically when he plays pseudonymously
    Henry — practitioner of The Love That Dare Not Speak Its Name (I suppose that’s intentional handball to qualify for the World Cup)

    Collin — ineluctible toe-poke of the tangible.
    Wondo — poor fool. Suffered from that phallic, mystic illusion–that an MLS #9 can make the National Team. His loss, and failure, is ours too.

    Dempsey– Will cross that road in order to fill an unvanquished spirit of struggle that could only be quenched, fulfilled, with a becoming historical envelopment borne of tireless unbeknownst illiterate striving through the steadfast, mind-hardening purity of raw sweat and labor of a dozen generations of ancestors, who cried out from their unmarked, unremarked graves to live, as he must, in that silent striving for only a posterity, only a history that will be cherished by generations unborn!
    Beckerman — Will die. In the rain.

Advanced Soccer Media
    1. About Us
    2. Terms and Conditions
    3. Privacy Policy
    4. Advertise with Us
    5. Jobs
    6. Contact Us
    7. NCAA Compliance
    1. 5855 Green Valley Circle, Ste. 303, Culver City, CA 90230
      © 2014 Advanced Sports Media, LLC. TeamRank™, Players to Watch™, and are trademarks Advanced Sports Media, LLC. All rights reserved.